Skip to content

Menu

Published By Toth Law & Toth Consulting
HomeBioOur ServicesContact
Search
Close

The Business of Benefits

Making Sense of Retirement Plan Layers and Complexities

The SECURE Act’s 403(b) Custodial Account “Distribution” Does Not Create IRAs

By Robert Toth on February 24, 2020
Posted in 403(b), SECURE Act

The SECURE ACT introduced a concept which was not known well beyond a handful of 403(b) practitioners, that is the “distribution” of 403(b) individual custodial accounts from 403(b) plans.  The lack of understanding of what this actually means has even lead one commentator in a highly respected trade organization’s technical piece to claim that this rule transforms 403(b) custodial accounts into IRAs.

Well, that is an easy one to settle: the “distributed” 403(b) custodial contract is NOT an IRA. It is simply a 403(b) contract which no longer has any relationship to a plan.

To more fully understand this, you really need to look at a bit of history.  As we’ve noted in the past, 403(b) contracts have really been around since 1918 or so, where they were considered to be the tax-favored purchase of a  retirement annuity for a teacher by a school. Unlike 401(a) arrangements-which are based on the concept of an employer run trust-403(b) plans are substantively based on an individual’s ownership of the retirement annuity, not by a formal pan with a trust structure.

Over the years, a number of employer based rules have come into play in the 403(b) market, one of which being the tax rule that a 403(b) plan cannot be fully terminated until all of the assets of a plan have been distributed within 12 months of the plan’s termination. Failing that, any distributions which were actually made during that 12 month period would lose their status as a qualifying rollover distribution, and those moving terminated 403(b) assets to an IRA would suffer all manner of tax penalties.

But how do you deal with the fact that a significant amount of 403(b) assets are held in investment contracts over which the plan sponsor has NO right to liquidate and distribute the assets (like in a 401(a) plan) upon plan termination? Well the 2007 403(b) regulations addressed this, by saying that a plan could “distribute” an annuity contract upon plan termination in a non-taxable “in-kind” distribution without liquidating the assets, which would then help fulfill this 12 month distribution requirement.

But then the IRS did something very odd. In spite of clear statutory language which treats 403(b)(7) custodial accounts in the same manner as 403(b)(1) annuity contracts, the IRS let it be widely known that it felt that 403(b) custodial accounts could NOT be “distributed” in the same manner as an annuity contract. This had the effect of freezing plan terminations if you could not convince ALL of your participants (even ex-employees) to liquidate and take a distribution of their investments being held in those custodial accounts.

SECURE Act Section 110 fixed this. 403(b) individual custodial accounts can now be distributed in the same manner as annuity contracts. What does this mean? According to the statute, those funds maintain their status as 403(b) contracts, not IRAs, and are subject to the 403(b) rules in effect at the time of the “distribution.”

Vendors have actually been doing this for decades (though I suspect many financial institution lawyers have not been aware of these practices over the years), out of necessity when a tax-exempt sponsor would disappear.

If done correctly, these distributions should be effective for ERISA purposes, as well as for Tax Code purposes. The question now becomes how do you actually distribute these contracts? There are a number of choices you have, and we are hopeful that the IRS will actually provide guidance on this point-and recognize as valid the good faith efforts in the past to distribute these contracts.

One last point: this rule, in effect, only can apply to individual a custodial contracts as opposed to those group custodial contracts which have become so popular in the past decade or so. The first reason is a practical one: virtually all master custodial accounts give the plan sponsor the right to liquidate participant assets upon plan termination, obviating the need to actually distribute a custodial account. The second reason is actually a legal one: a group custodial account is a contract between the employer and the vendor, not the participant. There is no vendor-participant contract to actually distribute, and I’ve never seen a group custodial account provide for the “spin-off” of an individual custodial account-unlike a group annuity contract, which will provide for the spin-off of an individual annuity certificate.

Here’s the verbiage from the statue:

SEC. 110. TREATMENT OF CUSTODIAL ACCOUNTS ON TERMINATION OF SECTION 403(b) PLANS.

Not later than six months after the date of enactment of this Act, the Secretary of the Treasury shall issue guidance to provide that, if an employer terminates the plan under which amounts are contributed to a custodial account under subparagraph (A) of section 403(b)(7), the plan administrator or custodian may dis- tribute an individual custodial account in kind to a participant or beneficiary of the plan and the distributed custodial account shall be maintained by the custodian on a tax-deferred basis as a section 403(b)(7) custodial account, similar to the treatment of fully-paid individual annuity contracts under Revenue Ruling 2011– 7, until amounts are actually paid to the participant or beneficiary. The guidance shall provide further (i) that the section 403(b)(7) status of the distributed custodial account is generally maintained if the custodial account thereafter adheres to the requirements of section 403(b) that are in effect at the time of the distribution of the account and (ii) that a custodial account would not be considered distributed to the participant or beneficiary if the employer has any material retained rights under the account (but the employer would not be treated as retaining material rights simply because the custodial account was originally opened under a group contract). Such guidance shall be retroactively effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2008.

 

 

Tags: 403(b) custodial account, 403(b) plan termination, Distribution of 403(b) Annuity Contracts, Distribution of 403(b) Custodial Accounts, SECURE Section 110
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Robert Toth Robert Toth

Bob Toth has more than 35 years of experience in employee benefits law. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products and services for retirement plans.

Read more about Robert TothRobert's Linkedin Profile
Related Posts
The 403(b) "Qualified Plan Distribution Annuity Contract" Under SECURE Section 109
August 30, 2021
QPDAC, DIA, QLAC, QPDA, GLWB, FIA, VA, RILA and Others: Welcome to the World of DC Lifetime Income
August 23, 2021
The Limited Utility of the "One Bad Apple" Rule Fix
August 16, 2021
More Resources

Firm Focus

Toth Law and Applied Pension Professionals support service providers who develop, distribute and maintain retirement plan products and services, as well as fiduciaries, boards, plan sponsors and individuals using these products. We provide unbiased advice related to complex product issues, ongoing administration and process improvement, and plan corrections.

Stay Connected

Subscribe via RSS Subscribe via RSS
Bob Toth on LinkedIn Bob Toth on LinkedIn
Conni Toth on LinkedIn Conni Toth on LinkedIn
Photo of Robert TothRobert TothPrincipal

Bob Toth has more than 35 years of experience in employee benefits law. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products…

Bob Toth has more than 35 years of experience in employee benefits law. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products and services for retirement plans.

Show more Show less
Photo of Conni TothConni TothManaging Pension Consultant

Conni Toth, co-founder and managing consultant for Applied Pension Professionals, LLC, brings more than 25 years of experience in retirement planning to the financial…

Conni Toth, co-founder and managing consultant for Applied Pension Professionals, LLC, brings more than 25 years of experience in retirement planning to the financial services industry.

Show more Show less

Topics

Archives

Recent Posts

  • Secure 2.0’s New QDRO Rules: The Mainstreaming of the QLAC?
  • Secure 2.0’s Unresolved 403(b) CIT Securities Law Issue
  • “Engineering” the Use of Individual Annuities In DC Lifetime Income Programs
  • Resetting the Mindset: DC Lifetime Income “Decumulation Accumulation” and their Risk-Related Restrictions
  • The “Entity” Difference Between 403(b) and 401(a) Plans
Law Office of Robert J. Toth, Jr., LLC
110 W. Berry, Ste 2106
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
Phone: (260) 387-6827
Fax: (260) 387-7485
Email: rjt@rtothlaw.com
Subscribe via RSS Bob Toth on LinkedIn Conni Toth on LinkedIn
Privacy PolicyDisclaimer
Copyright © 2023, Toth Law. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo