Skip to content

Menu

Published By Toth Law & Toth Consulting
HomeBioOur ServicesContact
Search
Close

The Business of Benefits

Making Sense of Retirement Plan Layers and Complexities

Mutual Funds and ERISA Accounts

By Robert Toth on April 24, 2012
Posted in Fiduciary Issues

Dave Walters, a partner from Bodman, and I led a rousing discussion on ERISA Accounts at the last meeting of the Great Lakes TEGE Council. It was an eye-opening discussion, with the Council members exploring a number of significant issues which many of us had not previously considered. Not only are there a number of ERISA rules to be considered, but our conversations also uncovered a few tax qualification rules as well.

"ERISA Account" is really not a defined term-anywhere-which is a problem in and of itself. So, for purposes of this piece, I refer to it as either an asset pool, or identifiable credits, that can be used at a plan’s direction for plan purposes.   It is interesting what happens when you take time to discuss things openly with other professionals; a lot gets flushed out.  One of the important things we discussed was the differences in ERISA Accounts depending on the funding source. Working the details of the ERISA Account really involves working the details of the underlying investment product.  

Just take just one iteration of how ERISA Accounts can be funded, 12b-1 fees from mutual funds, for example. Though plan assets are used to purchase investment company shares, the actual assets within the mutual fund are not considered plan assets because of very specific ERISA rules (the shares owned by the plan are actually the plan assets; the underlying investments of the mutual fund itself are not). The mutual fund is governed by a board of directors, which is responsible for adopting any 12b-1 program that the fund has, and the program determines whether or not such funds are even payable to a plan to fund an ERISA Account. Any 12b-1 fees are paid by the mutual fund itself, not by the investment manager of the fund or the rep selling/advising-on the fund (though those parties may, themselves, be able to create ERISA Accounts if done properly, but not from mutual fund assets).  Though these 12b-1 fees may be considered indirect compensation for 408b-2 purposes, and even though they may be subtracted from the fund’s value in determining the daily Net Asset Value of the shares held by the plan, the payment of the 12b-1 fee itself would not, generally be considered the payment of a plan asset.

One of the issues discussed was whether, if the plan had the legal right to that payment, whether that payment is a plan asset (or is the right to the payment an asset?).

If the 12b-1 payment is made to the plan’s trust, it is a plan asset. But what if, instead, it is paid directly to the TPA, who uses it to offset administrative costs under its contract with the plan? Is it a plan asset? What about the advisor, or the plan’s investment manager (particularly if it also manages the underlying mutual fund?).

This is just one example. Even within mutual funds, there are a variety of ways to handle the ERISA Account, and just wait until we discuss annuity contracts and collective trusts.  Determination of the plan asset status is just one of the issues (albeit a critical one) for any iteration of an ERISA Accounts, and we understand there is a pending DOL Advisory Opinion request somehow dealing with this sort of issue.  But then there are the questions of its accounting and treatment under the plan, the allocation issues, the forfeiture account issues, and even whether or not "definitely determinable benefit" becomes an issue if too much discretion on allocation is granted under the plan document. 

The only thing really clear is that there are a number of issues to resolve and, like prohibited transactions, the answers to them will lie in the specifics of the design of the ERISA Account; what type of entity funds it (and its relationship to fiduciaries and other parties in interest); how it is used; how it is terminated; what kind of contract commitment is involved; how is it documented and substantiated; how does it work in 403(b);  and others.

Whew. Here we go again……

 

 

Tags: ERISA Account, ERISA Recapture account
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Robert Toth Robert Toth

Bob Toth has practicing employee benefits law since 1983. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products and services for retirement plans.

Read more about Robert TothRobert's Linkedin Profile
Related Posts
Resetting the Mindset: DC Lifetime Income "Decumulation Accumulation" and their Risk-Related Restrictions
November 29, 2022
Master Custodial Accounts and the 403b Self Directed Brokerage Account
June 29, 2021
The DOL's Final ESG Investment Rules May Force Reassessment of "Church Plan Status" for Some Organizations
November 9, 2020
More Resources

Firm Focus

Toth Law and Applied Pension Professionals support service providers who develop, distribute and maintain retirement plan products and services, as well as fiduciaries, boards, plan sponsors and individuals using these products. We provide unbiased advice related to complex product issues, ongoing administration and process improvement, and plan corrections.

Stay Connected

Subscribe via RSS Subscribe via RSS
Bob Toth on LinkedIn Bob Toth on LinkedIn
Conni Toth on LinkedIn Conni Toth on LinkedIn
Photo of Robert TothRobert TothPrincipal

Bob Toth has practicing employee benefits law since 1983. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products and services for retirement…

Bob Toth has practicing employee benefits law since 1983. His practice focuses on the design, administration and distribution of financial products and services for retirement plans.

Show more Show less
Photo of Conni TothConni TothManaging Pension Consultant

Conni Toth, co-founder and managing consultant for Applied Pension Professionals, LLC, brings more than 25 years of experience in retirement planning to the financial…

Conni Toth, co-founder and managing consultant for Applied Pension Professionals, LLC, brings more than 25 years of experience in retirement planning to the financial services industry.

Show more Show less

Topics

Archives

Recent Posts

  • The 403(b) CIT and the 12 Month Put
  • Secure 2.0’s New QDRO Rules: The Mainstreaming of the QLAC?
  • Secure 2.0’s Unresolved 403(b) CIT Securities Law Issue
  • “Engineering” the Use of Individual Annuities In DC Lifetime Income Programs
  • Resetting the Mindset: DC Lifetime Income “Decumulation Accumulation” and their Risk-Related Restrictions
Law Office of Robert J. Toth, Jr., LLC
110 W. Berry, Ste 2106
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
Phone: (260) 387-6827
Fax: (260) 387-7485
Email: rjt@rtothlaw.com
Subscribe via RSS Bob Toth on LinkedIn Conni Toth on LinkedIn
Privacy PolicyDisclaimer
Copyright © 2023, Toth Law. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo